Bloomberg

Volatility Grips Stocks as Fed Remains Hawkish: Markets Wrap

(Bloomberg) — US stocks dropped after Federal Reserve officials continued to hammer home the message that they’ll keep raising interest rates to battle inflation, especially after fresh data showed the economy can handle further central-bank tightening. 

The S&P 500 fell as much as 2.9% after roaring back from a six-day slide on Wednesday. The tech-heavy Nasdaq 100 dropped nnearly 4% after St. Louis Fed President James Bullard didn’t back down from his hawkish stance and said investors have now understood that they can’t escape additional rate hikes in coming months. Tech stocks are vulnerable to higher interest rates, which threaten to diminish the value of companies’ future earnings. 

US Treasuries pared earlier losses, with the 10-year yield hovering around 3.75%. UK gilt yields rose after Prime Minister Liz Truss’s defense of unfunded tax cuts that sent markets into turmoil failed to persuade investors. 

Investors are contending with threats posed by discordant moves from central banks over the past few days, with Fed officials adamant on further monetary tightening, the Bank of England unveiling a plan to support government debt and authorities in Asia trying to prop up weakening currencies.

“I was actually really surprised by the impact that the Bank of England had on the global market,” said Fiona Cincotta, senior financial markets analyst at City Index. “Yet, it was short-lived, the relief rally. We sort of pushed past that quite quickly and it seems to be back to that narrative of inflation fears, higher-interest-rate fears.”

Fed officials haven’t shied away from warning that more rate-hike pain is yet to come, with Cleveland Fed President Loretta Mester echoing the rhetoric that her colleagues reinforced this week. Better-than-expected 2Q core PCE and personal consumption numbers on Thursday also paved the path for the Fed to stay aggressive. Weekly jobless claims fell to the lowest since April, showing a persistently tight labor market.

Recession concerns persisted as a gap in the government’s two primary measures of US economic activity during the first half of 2022 narrowed. The National Bureau of Economic Research’s Business Cycle Dating Committee uses this metric and other variables to make any recession call.

The Cboe Volatility Index, or VIX, which is Wall Street’s widely followed gauge of fear, has been showing signs of stress this week. It hadn’t pierced 30 since June, but has been there every day this week. Volatility has also crept into the US swap market in recent days.

“The market is now coming to terms with the idea that a recession is almost a given at this point and it’s really making adjustments for that,” said Shawn Snyder, head of investment strategy at Citi US Wealth Management. 

Separately, the European Commission announced an eighth package of sanctions that would include a price cap on Russia’s oil exports as Russia vowed to go ahead with the annexation of the parts of Ukraine that its troops currently control after UN-condemned votes, putting the Kremlin on a fresh collision course with the US and its allies.

How much damage is a strong dollar causing? That’s the theme of this week’s MLIV Pulse survey. It’s brief and we don’t collect your name or any contact information. Please click here to share your views.

Key events this week:

  • Fed’s Mary Daly speak at an event, Thursday
  • China PMI, Friday
  • Euro zone CPI, unemployment, Friday
  • US consumer income , University of Michigan consumer sentiment, Friday
  • Fed’s Lael Brainard and John Williams speak, Friday

Some of the main moves in markets:

Stocks

  • The S&P 500 fell 2.5% as of 2:40 p.m. New York time
  • The Nasdaq 100 fell 3.5%
  • The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 1.9%
  • The MSCI World index rose 1.1%

Currencies

  • The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index fell 0.3%
  • The euro rose 0.6% to $0.9795
  • The British pound rose 1.7% to $1.1069
  • The Japanese yen fell 0.2% to 144.40 per dollar

Cryptocurrencies

  • Bitcoin fell 0.9% to $19,393.74
  • Ether fell 1% to $1,337.39

Bonds

  • The yield on 10-year Treasuries advanced two basis points to 3.75%
  • Germany’s 10-year yield advanced six basis points to 2.18%
  • Britain’s 10-year yield advanced 13 basis points to 4.14%

Commodities

  • West Texas Intermediate crude fell 0.9% to $81.43 a barrel
  • Gold futures fell 0.2% to $1,666.50 an ounce

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Meta Announces Hiring Freeze, Warns Employees of Restructuring

(Bloomberg) — Meta Platforms Inc., the owner of Facebook and Instagram, said it will freeze hiring and restructure some teams in an effort to cut costs and shift priorities. 

Chief Executive Officer Mark Zuckerberg announced the social networking company’s freeze during a weekly Q&A session with employees, according to a person in attendance. He added that the company would reduce budgets across most teams, even teams that are growing, and that individual teams will sort out how to handle headcount changes — whether that means not filling roles that employees depart, shifting people to other teams, or working to “manage out people who aren’t succeeding,” according to remarks reviewed by Bloomberg.

“I had hoped the economy would have more clearly stabilized by now, but from what we’re seeing it doesn’t yet seem like it has, so we want to plan somewhat conservatively,” Zuckerberg said. A Meta spokesperson declined to comment.

Meta’s further cost cuts and hiring freeze are its starkest admission that advertising revenue growth is slowing, amid mounting competition for users’ attention. Meta said earlier this year that it was planning to slow hiring for some management roles, and had postponed handing out full-time jobs to summer interns.  The freeze was necessary because “we want to make sure we’re not adding people to teams where we don’t expect to have roles next year,” Zuckerberg explained.

Zuckerberg had warned in July that that Meta would “steadily reduce headcount growth,” and that “many teams are going to shrink so we can shift energy to other areas.” Priorities internally include Reels, Meta’s TikTok competitor, and Zuckerberg’s futuristic plan for the internet, known as the metaverse. Meta had more than 83,500 employees as of June 30, and added 5,700 new hires in the second quarter. Zuckerberg said the company would be “somewhat smaller” by the end of 2023.

“For the first 18 years of the company, we basically grew quickly basically every year, and then more recently our revenue has been flat to slightly down for the first time,” he told staff Thursday.

During its first-quarter earnings call, the company said annual expenses would be roughly $3 billion lower than initially projected, trimming an estimated range that had been as high as $95 billion.  In prior moves to reduce spending, a dual-camera watch the company was building to compete with the Apple Watch was shuttered.

(Adds Zuckerberg remarks obtained by Bloomberg.)

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Musk Sought ‘Trump’ Word Search to Prove Twitter Fake Accounts

(Bloomberg) — Elon Musk wanted Twitter Inc. to include the word “Trump” in a search of corporate communications and documents to better understand the company’s problem with fake accounts, unsealed documents show. 

“Trump is relevant for the reasons we explained, namely that the name is often associated with spam, false accounts, and bots,” Musk attorney Silpa Maruri said in a July 29 email exchange that’s part of a trove of documents made public Thursday in a lawsuit over the billionaire’s attempt to cancel his $44 billion acquisition offer.

Musk backed out of the deal in part because he claimed Twitter wasn’t forthcoming about the number of bot accounts at the social-media company, which sued Musk to force him to complete the deal.

Former President Donald Trump, once one of Twitter’s most popular users, was kicked off the platform after the Jan. 6 attack on the Capitol, and Musk has said Trump should “sail into the sunset” rather than run for election again. Twitter and other platforms have been widely used by bots to spread misinformation, including about Trump and the 2020 election he lost to President Joe Biden.

Twitter lawyer Bradley Wilson responded to the search-term dispute saying the company was “unpersuaded” by the need to look for “Trump.” The former president’s name is among “many irrelevant subjects” that would result in too many search results, he said. 

Lawyers for the parties also clashed over the search terms “Bangalore” and “New Delhi,” according to the emails. Musk’s lawyers said they wanted the terms added because they “recently learned Twitter filed a lawsuit against the government in Bangalore challenging orders blocking certain user accounts.”

Twitter failed to disclose the investigations in India and by doing so violated a provision of the merger agreement, Musk’s lawyer claimed.

“That Twitter filed suit in response to blocking orders already issued strongly suggests an investigation(s) had been underway during the negotiation period and before the time the Merger Agreement was executed,” according to the email.

A preliminary search with the terms and many others sought by Musk turned up nearly 250,000 documents from the list of individuals whose emails and records were searched, Twitter said, arguing the terms should be narrowed.

EXPLAINER: How Musk’s Twitter Deal Foundered Over ‘Spam Bots’

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Google Winds Down Stadia Game-Streaming Service Three Years After Launch

(Bloomberg) — Google said it will terminate services for Stadia, its troubled cloud gaming service, after it failed to gain traction with players almost three years after its launch. 

Stadia was an attempt from Alphabet Inc.’s Google to take on the video game console giants with a platform of its own. Unlike traditional consoles, Stadia allowed users to play games on devices such as Android phones and Chromecast apps for TV, by funneling data directly from Google’s server clusters. Its subscription cost $10 a month.

“While Stadia’s approach to streaming games for consumers was built on a strong technology foundation, it hasn’t gained the traction with users that we expected,” Phil Harrison, Stadia vice president and general manager, wrote in a blog post on Thursday. “So we’ve made the difficult decision to begin winding down our Stadia streaming service.”

Players will be able to access their games library and play through Jan. 18. Google will refund Stadia hardware purchases, games and add-on content made through the Google Store, Harrison said.

Google’s Stadia Problem? A Video Game Unit That’s Not Googley Enough

Google invested generously in Stadia in an effort to reach well beyond the audience of traditional gamers or those who couldn’t afford a pricey Xbox or PlayStation console. It shelled out tens of millions of dollars to get games like Red Dead Redemption 2 on the platform, Bloomberg has reported. 

Stadia debuted in November 2019 with popular third-party franchises including Destiny 2 and Assassin’s Creed Odyssey. But Google’s ultimate goal was to pack Stadia with original content and the company hired hundreds of game developers from Montreal and Los Angeles. They didn’t have long to ramp up before Google shuttered its in-house game development in early 2021. People familiar with the studio said at the time that the rule-bound tech giant struggled to foster an environment nurturing to video game development, which is interdisciplinary and can be chaotic. The impact of Covid-19 spurred a hiring freeze at Google, which presented challenges for staffing up the division.

Gamers also chafed at the idea that games they purchased for $60 a piece didn’t feel like they belonged to them, since they were stored in the cloud — a concern validated by Thursday’s shutdown notice. Accustomed to owning their own hardware, some gamers felt like Stadia appeared too jarring of a shift. The service missed its sales targets on controllers and monthly active users by hundreds of thousands, Bloomberg has reported. 

With the exit of Stadia, that leaves Amazon.com Inc.’s Luna, Microsoft Corp.’s xCloud and Nvidia Corp.’s GeForce Now to chart the future of cloud gaming.

(Updates with additional context from fourth paragraph.)

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Ukraine Latest: Russia to Annex Regions in Plan Condemned by UN

(Bloomberg) — Russia plans to sign treaties Friday to absorb four occupied regions of Ukraine after annexation votes condemned by the United Nations as illegal. President Vladimir Putin also plans to address legislators on Friday, his spokesman said. 

Putin may face an early test of his annexation plans in the Donetsk town of Lyman, where Ukrainian, Western and Russian military analysts say Russian units are at risk of being enveloped.

NATO allies on Thursday said damage to the Nord Stream 1 and 2 natural gas pipelines appear to be “the result of deliberate, reckless and irresponsible acts of sabotage.” The Swedish Coast Guard’s Command Center also identified a new pipeline leak in the Baltic Sea.  

 

(See RSAN on the Bloomberg Terminal for the Russian Sanctions Dashboard.)

Key Developments

  • Ukraine Advance Near Lyman Challenges Putin Annexation Move
  • Putin Set to Annex Ukraine Lands Friday, Ignoring Criticism
  • More US Artillery Prized by Ukrainians Won’t Arrive for Years
  • Putin’s Draft Order Sends 200,000 Russians Fleeing to the Border
  • Nord Stream Gas Pipes Now Have Four Leaks With Another Found 
  • Ukraine’s Plea for Tanks Bogs Down as US, Germany Confront Risks

On the Ground

Russia struck the city of Dnipro with missiles overnight, including residential areas, local authorities said on Telegram. Three people, including a child, were killed. More than 60 private houses and several high-rise buildings were damaged. On Wednesday evening Russia launched five missiles toward the Dnipropetrovsk and Zaporizhzhia regions, four of which were destroyed by air-defense forces, while one hit a grain-processing facility in Kryvorizka district, the Ukrainian military’s southern command said on Facebook. More than 28 settlements, including Mykolaiv, Kryvyi Rih and Siversk, incurred Russian strikes over the past day, Ukraine’s General Staff said. Russian forces shelled the Kryvorizka district Thursday morning, hitting industrial infrastructure and wounding 13 workers, according to regional authorities. 

All times CET:

Putin Says Mistakes Were Made in Russian Mobilization (7:40 p.m.)

Acknowledging errors in Russia’s military mobilization, Putin told a meeting of his Security Council that “it’s necessary to correct all mistakes and prevent them from happening in the future.”

The mobilization of about 300,000 reservists has been met with protests in Russian cities and thousands of military-age men fleeing the country.

While the criteria for being called up included previous service in the armed forces and relevant experience, some of the Russians told to report for duty were entitled to a delay, such as fathers with many children, those with chronic diseases and those past military age, according to Putin.

Ukraine Says Foreign Aid Declined in September (7:16 p.m.)

Ukraine received about $2 billion of financial aid in September from international partners, down from $4.7 billion in the previous month, Finance Minister Serhiy Marchenko said.

“That is not the amount which we expected,” Marchenko said on Ukrainian TV. However “as we have leftovers from the previous periods and budget revenue rose compared with the beginning of the war, we are now more calmly looking at our needs.”

The government expects to get 8 billion euros ($7.8 billion) from the European Union by the end of the year and “thus I don’t see any problems,” Marchenko said. Ukraine has estimated that it needs $5 billion a month in foreign aid to cover budget needs.

Montenegro Declares Russian Diplomats Persona Non Grata (7:11  p.m.)

Six Russian diplomats in Montenegro have been declared persone non grata, Tass news agency reported, citing a Twitter post on the page of the Montenegrin foreign ministry’s press office. Russia will give “an appropriate response,” Tass reported, citing the nation’s foreign ministry.

Earlier on Thursday several Montenegrin citizens were detained in Podgorica on suspicion of having worked for Russian intelligence, Vijesti reported, citing unidentified people with knowledge.

UN’s Guterres Says Russian Annexation ‘Has No Place in Modern World’ (6:44 p.m.)

United Nations Secretary-General Antonio Guterres condemned Russia’s annexation announcement as a violation of international law and the UN charter.

“Any decision to proceed with the annexation of Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions of Ukraine would have no legal value and deserves to be condemned,” he said. “It cannot be reconciled with the international legal framework. It stands against everything the international community is meant to stand for. It flouts the purposes and principles of the United Nations. It is a dangerous escalation. It has no place in the modern world. It must not be accepted.”

Ukrainian President President Volodymyr Zelenskiy expressed appreciation in a tweet for the clear statement by Guterres on Russia’s “criminal intention” to annex more land.

 

Most Russians Alarmed by Military Call-Up, Poll Shows (5:51 p.m.)

Most Russians were alarmed at Putin’s decision to order a “partial mobilization” after major battlefield losses in Ukraine, and slightly more are concerned that their war on their neighbor is going badly, an opinion poll showed.

According to the survey by the independent Levada Center, 70% of respondents had feelings of fear, alarm or shock after Putin ordered the call-up, with many worrying that a full-scale nationwide draft will follow. A total of 66% believe that’s a possibility, compared with 28% in February. 

While a wide majority of those polled said they still supported the invasion, the share of Russians saying the conflict isn’t going well increased to 31% from 17% in April. More respondents – 48% – now back peace talks, versus 44% a month earlier. 

Russia Says Mobilized Troops Will Be Used for ‘Defense’ (5:20 p.m.)

Russia said mobilized troops will be for the “defense” of the territories it occupies in Ukraine, as fear of being sent to the front lines of the invasion has led hundreds of thousands of draft-aged men to flee the country.

The Defense Ministry said that the mobilized troops would receive training and then be deployed to “control and defend” territory held by Russia, Interfax reported. Ukraine has steadily pushed Russian forces back in recent weeks, but the Kremlin is moving ahead with plans to annex the areas it holds, as well as laying claim to neighboring regions that Kyiv controls. The UN has denounced Russia’s annexation plans as illegal and illegitimate.

Russia to Hide Over $110 Billion in Secret Budget Spending (3:59 p.m.)

Russia will hide the purpose of almost a quarter of its planned spending next year, as it redraws the budget for a longer war in Ukraine and prepares to annex parts of its neighbor’s territory.

A draft 2023 budget allocates approximately 6.5 trillion rubles ($112 billion) in classified or unspecified outlays, according to Bloomberg calculations based on the document.

The level of secrecy is unprecedented and reflects Russia’s increasing reluctance to open up its books to scrutiny since Putin’s invasion of Ukraine. The government has already stopped publishing key statistics including a detailed breakdown of trade.

Estonia Rattled by UK Troop Scale-Down Plan (3:45 p.m.)

Estonian leaders were alarmed by a report that Britain would scale down its troop presence in the Baltic nation before Christmas.

The number of British soldiers in Estonia was doubled to about 2,000 in February as an additional safeguard after Russia invaded Ukraine. The UK plans to pull out a 700-strong battalion at the end of the year, as reported by the Times on Wednesday. 

Ukraine Gets Back More POWs from Mariupol (1:41 p.m.)

Ukraine negotiated the release of six more prisoners of war from Russia, including four soldiers who were captured defending the port city of Mariupol, Andriy Yermak, President Volodymyr Zelenskiy’s chief of staff, said on Telegram.

 “Our goal is to get all of our people back,” Yermak said. “We are working on this non-stop.”

EU Says Ready to Make Russia Pay ‘Heavy Price’ (1:22 p.m.)

The European Commission doesn’t accept Russia’s “sham” referendums aimed at annexing Ukrainian territories, spokeswoman Dana Spinant said in Brussels.

“We will never accept any annexation of territory or any land-grabbing by Russia,” Spinant said. “We are ready to make the Kremlin pay a hefty price for this new escalation in the conflict.”

Finland to Mostly Halt Russian Tourist Arrivals (12:48 p.m.)

Finland’s government decided to heavily curtail Russian tourist arrivals into the country, including putting an end to people transiting through the Nordic nation to elsewhere in Europe. 

Finland will stop issuing tourist visas to Russians and plans to invalidate their tourist visas at the border, Foreign Minister Pekka Haavisto told reporters. The decision will come into force on Friday.

Putin to Push Ahead With Annexing Ukraine Regions (12:02 p.m.)

Russia’s president will sign treaties on Friday to absorb four regions in eastern and southern Ukraine following annexation votes condemned as illegal by Kyiv’s government and the United Nations. 

Putin will hold a ceremony and later make an address to legislators and other officials, his spokesman said. The final formalities of annexation are expected to be completed next week. 

The move puts the Kremlin on a fresh collision course with the US and its allies. Putin has threatened to use “all the means at our disposal” to defend Russia, a signal he may use nuclear weapons to defend the lands he’s annexing. 

Read more: Putin to Push Ahead With Annexing Ukraine Lands After Sham Votes

Regulator Says Germany Using Too Much Gas (11:43 a.m.)

Germany’s network regulator warned that households and companies used too much gas over the past week as temperatures dropped, and said savings of at least 20% are needed to avert a shortage of the fuel this winter.

Klaus Mueller, Bundesnetzagentur president, called the figures “sobering,” while cautioning that they provide only a “snapshot” and that the situation can quickly change.

Read more: Germany’s Network Regulator Sounds Alarm on Gas Consumption

Three Ships Leaves Ukraine’s Odesa-Area Ports (11:20 a.m.)

Three ships carrying Ukrainian agriculture products left the ports of Chornomorsk and Pivdennyi on the Black Sea on Thursday, the government said. 

The ships are bound for Africa and Asia, with cargoes including 27,500 tons of wheat to Tunisia. Ukraine has exported almost 5.5 million tons of agriculture products from three Black Sea ports since a safe-transit deal was reached with Russia in late July.

NATO Promises ‘Determined’ Response to Infrastructure Attacks (11:09 a.m.)

NATO allies warned that any deliberate attack against allies’ infrastructure would be met with a “united and determined response,” following gas pipeline leaks in the Baltic Sea discovered this week. 

In a joint statement, the North Atlantic Council echoed other officials, saying information currently indicates the leaks are the result of “deliberate, reckless and irresponsible acts of sabotage.” They added they are committed to defending against any “coercive use of energy or hybrid tactics by state and non-state actors.” 

Even as Poland has blamed Russia for the damage, the NATO statement refrained from naming any names as a joint investigation by Denmark, Sweden and Germany is under way.

Albania Says It Welcomes Russians, Lithuania Urges Citizens to Leave (11 a.m.) 

Albanian Prime Minister Edi Rama said Russians fleeing the country are “welcome” in Albania, according to Tirana-based portal Albanian Daily News. When it comes to the Balkan region, the Russian exodus so far has been focused on Serbia. 

In Lithuania, Defence Minister Arvydas Anusauskas reiterated advise for the country’s citizens to leave Russia, saying it’s “becoming a state where foreign citizens can simply become hostages” to the Kremlin regime. “No one can rule out that they won’t use foreign citizens as shields,” he said. 

Finland Sees Russia Turning More to Cyber-Spying (10:14 a.m.)

The war in Ukraine and the expulsions of Russian diplomats that followed have hampered Moscow’s espionage operations, causing the country increasingly to turn to the cyber environment for intelligence gathering, the Finnish Security and Intelligence Service, Supo, said in a national security overview.

Russia’s traditional method of spying is to use human intelligence under diplomatic cover and that has now “become substantially more difficult,” SUPO said. 

The security agency said authoritarian states “can secure access to or influence over critical infrastructure” via corporate acquisitions or investments. It identified China as a potential perpetrator, alongside Russia.

Read more: Finland Sees Russia Moving Espionage to Cyber Environment

Russian Stocks Brush Off New Sanctions Threat (9:32 a.m.)

Russia’s equity benchmark gained for a third day, trimming this month’s losses, as investors disregarded the threat of additional international sanctions and took advantage of the cheapest valuations on record.

The MOEX Russia Index gained as much as 2.1% on Thursday; it traded up 0.7% as of 10:30am in Moscow. 

Retailer H&M Takes Earnings Hit From Russian Exit (9:03 a.m.)

Retailer Hennes & Mauritz AB plans to cut costs by 2 billion Swedish kronor ($180 million) annually after its exit from Russia and higher garment and transport costs caused earnings to slump.

Operating profit dropped 86% in the three months through August. The figure includes a previously communicated one-time charge of 2 billion kronor for winding down operations in Russia. 

Fourth Nord Stream Leak Found by Sweden’s Coast Guard (8:30 a.m.) 

A new leak has been discovered on the Nord Stream 1 and 2 gas pipelines in the Baltic Sea, bringing the total number of ruptures to four, according to the Swedish Coast Guard’s Command Center. 

Gas has been bubbling up from the pipelines since earlier this week, with Denmark estimating that the links would empty by Sunday. Several governments have called the actions “deliberate” and “sabotage.” 

Lithuania’s Foreign Minister Gabrielius Landesbergis said the news was more evidence that the leaks are deliberate and “fit to be called a terrorist act.” 

Read more: Nord Stream Gas Pipes Now Have Four Leaks With Another Found 

Finland Reports Clear Drop in Russian Arrivals (8:21 a.m.)

Finland’s Border Guard said about 4,700 Russians crossed the border into the Nordic country on Wednesday, a “clear drop” compared with Tuesday, when more than 7,000 entered. 

Wednesday’s arrivals are comparable with the numbers from a week ago, when Vladimir Putin’s expanded military mobilization was announced. 

The UK defence ministry said that the Russian exodus in the past week “likely exceeds the size of the total invasion force Russia field in February,” with the better-off and well educated over-represented. 

(A previous version of this story was corrected to remove an erroneous “Thursday” from the headline.)

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Nikola Founder Bought Utah Ranch With ‘Worthless’ Options

(Bloomberg) — Nikola Corp. founder Trevor Milton’s hype about the electric truck startup’s prospects lulled a real estate investor into accepting millions of dollars in Nikola stock options as partial payment for a 4,600-acre ranch, he told the jury in Milton’s criminal fraud trial.  

The investor, Peter Hicks, testified on Wednesday that he was first contacted in March 2020 with an offer from Milton to pay $5 million in cash to buy the Wasatch Creeks Ranch, a sprawling Utah property 12 miles from Salt Lake City that features five miles of pristine fishing streams, which Hicks had bought earlier that month for $6.85 million. 

The Massachusetts investor rejected the offer, and Milton came back a month later with an offer of $7.5 million in cash and $7.5 million in Nikola stock options.

Hicks told the jurors in federal court in Manhattan that he was wary because he had never heard of Nikola or Milton and didn’t like the looks of a purchase funded partly by stock in a company without revenue, calling it “pretty risky.” 

“I believe in things that are very tangible to me, and that is real estate and cash,” Hicks testified. 

Changed His Mind

Then, after a conference call with Milton that same month, Hicks changed his mind. On the call, Hicks testified, Milton told him the company already had $14 million in truck orders and an agreement with Anheuser-Busch to use Nikola trucks on a delivery route between Los Angeles and Phoenix. Hicks told the jury Milton’s assurances that Nikola had begun procuring charging stations for 13 routes meant it had contracts in place, a “crucial” piece of information for him.

“A pre-revenue company, I needed convincing to be even slightly interested in any of this,” Hicks said, explaining that he needed “something tangible to show they would produce substantial revenue.” The charging stations clinched it, he said.

Hicks said he agreed to sell the ranch that June and got $8.5 million in cash and options to purchase 515,095 Nikola shares at a below-market price, which were valued at $15 million when the deal closed in August 2020. That month, the stock was trading at more than $40 a share. But by December, when Hicks was first able to exercise the options, they had plunged to as little as $13.51. That was below the $16.50 strike price on the options, which made them “worthless,” he said.

Hicks said he never paid attention to the company’s Securities and Exchange Commission filings because all of his impressions of the company came from the conference call.

‘False Representations’

“This information was being conveyed to me by the founder and the CEO of Nikola, of a many-billion-dollar company,” Hicks testified. “It never struck me he would be making false representations — in fact, made false representations. I thought it all to be credible and true.”

Milton was freed pending trial on $100 million bail secured by two properties he owns in Utah — one of them the ranch, according to a civil suit Hicks filed against Milton. Milton paid $32.5 million for another ranch near Salt Lake City in August 2019, the highest sale price ever recorded for a residential property in the state. A 16,800-square-foot home on the property, called Riverband Ranch, boasts nine bedrooms, nine bathrooms and hickory floors.

Nikola went public through a reverse merger with a blank check company in June 2020 in a deal that made Milton into a billionaire several times over. At one point, the company’s shares ballooned to almost $80 each, giving Nikola a market capitalization greater than Ford Motor Co., all with scant revenue. Nikola’s market value plummeted after Milton and the company were accused of exaggerating the capability of its debut truck, the Nikola One. 

Prosecutors accused Milton of making false and misleading statements on social media and other outlets to induce retail investors to buy the stock, and of wire fraud for deceiving Hicks, who sued Milton in federal court in Utah in March 2022 over the deal. 

Milton’s lawyers contend that their client never intended to deceive any investors, was just following the company’s marketing plan and never said anything he didn’t believe to be true.

Made $3.2 Million

Hicks’s testimony came in the trial’s third week and near the end of the government’s case against Milton. Under cross-examination Thursday by Milton lawyer Torrey Young, Hicks admitted he made $3.2 million on the deal — a profit of $1.6 million from the cash portion plus $1.6 million from a sale of stock he bought from Milton below market price in March 2021 as they tried to resolve their dispute.

Hicks said he eventually decided to sue Milton for more than $45 million in March 2022 after further negotiations stalled, including a proposed transaction in which Milton would buy another property from Hicks. Hicks testified that he didn’t exercise the stock options when he was able to in December 2020, with the shares above the strike price, because of the risk.

“You would have been in the money?” Young asked.

“You’re putting $8 million up, you better be wise in your decisions,” Hicks said, adding that even in the brief time it would have taken to exercise the options, the volatile shares could have sunk.

“You just wanted more money, correct?” Young asked.

“No, I wanted to make a prudent decision, and it would not be prudent to exercise on those days,” Hicks responded.

The case is US v. Milton, 21-cr-478, US District Court, Southern District of New York (Manhattan.)

(Adds Hicks’s testimony under questioning by Milton lawyer in last section.)

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Ferrari Owner Elkann Says Energy Transition Shakeup Could Create a New Tesla

(Bloomberg) — John Elkann, the scion of Italy’s Agnelli clan, sees potential for a “new Tesla” to emerge from the current wave of energy transition at a time his family’s Exor NV holding is investing in startups, including some focused on cleaner sources.

“There’s a lot of excitement in energy transition, and not just for automotive, at some point I guess you’ll have a trillion-dollar company coming from here,” Elkann, 46, said in an interview Wednesday at his office inside Turin’s Fondazione Agnelli building. 

Energy transition is a theme that’s already gotten the Agnellis’ attention, and among its roughly 70 startup investments, the holding has bets on everything from a new-generation nuclear power generator to a unicorn company focused on converting natural gas flares into Bitcoin power.  

Exor’s early-stage capital branch has invested about €1 billion ($970 million) in startups over the last five years, as the Agnellis diversifying their traditional automotive holdings: the biggest stake in Stellantis NV and control of Ferrari NV. 

Exor, whose net asset value totaled about €31 billion at the end of June, earlier this year cashed out $9 billion through the sale of reinsurer PartnerRe to France’s Covea. The holding now plans to focus on expansion in health and luxury, as well as on technology, which Elkann says isn’t an alternative to other industries but a complementary area of focus.

“With the mobility sector having started its most radical transformation in over a century, we started getting involved in the tech industry five years ago, as well working with the venture capital world,” Elkann said. 

Elkann, speaking ahead of the Italian Tech Week forum in Turin, where he serves as organizer, also gave some hints on Exor’s investment strategy. 

“I can’t rule out at some point in the future a big deal in the tech industry by Exor,” Elkann said. “But that’s not our current focus, and we much prefer a step-by-step approach to accompany startups.”  

The Agnellis recently rebranded Exor Seeds, their early-stage arm, as Exor Ventures, to underscore a commitment to venture capitalism. The holding last year tapped Diego Piacentini, a veteran of both Apple Inc. and Amazon.com Inc., as chairman of the unit. 

In the interview, Elkann reaffirmed the billionaire family’s commitment to Italy, highlighting how it’s working with young entrepreneurs. Exor is also pushing its Vento program, which is set to provide up to €150,000 in financing to dozens of early-stage Italian startups. 

The Agnelli clan leader said he sees potential for startups and tech in Italy, where the family’s Fiat SpA once dominated a manufacturing-heavy industrial landscape. 

Now, Italian unicorn companies are emerging, especially in fintech, including payments specialist Scalapay Srl and mobile digital platform Satispay SpA, which earlier this week completed a €320 million round of fund-raising that values it at more than €1 billion. 

For Exor, recent bets include US-based biotech Altos Labs Inc., which focuses on cellular rejuvenation programming. On the real estate side, the holding earlier this year pumped about €100 million into Italian digital company Casavo, which offers instant solutions for buyers and sellers of property.

Some of Exor’s other bets are clearly linked to the current energy transition trend, with the holding recently investing in London-based nuclear startup Newcleo, a company looking at ways to cut development and production costs for nuclear power so it can play a bigger role in the transition away from fossil fuels. 

Another Exor play on transition is Crusoe Energy Systems, a Denver-based firm that works with energy companies to capture surplus gas, converting byproducts into electricity to power data centers and crypto-mining operations.

But even with an ever-more diverse investment portfolio, Exor is still making bets on transportation. Exor paid $200 million in 2020 for a stake in ride-share specialist Via Transportation Inc., which designs software for transit systems to allow them to provide on-demand alternatives to fixed route service. 

And in a highly symbolic move, the Agnellis essentially safeguarded the future of the historic Turin Mirafiori plant, as Stellantis transformed the factory into a hub for battery-powered vehicles including the electric version of the Fiat 500.

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

OneFootball Buys Startup to Target Women as Fans Flock to Game

(Bloomberg) — OneFootball has named soccer-startup founder Victoire Cogevina to a new role to expand its audience for women’s games, and has agreed to buy her startup, Gloria.

Gloria, which is building an app to offer hubs for fans to chat and share content about their teams, will be integrated into OneFootball, the companies said in a statement. Cogevina will join the company as vice president of women’s soccer.

In that role, she’ll help the Berlin-based company pursue new investments and partnerships to attract fans of the women’s games, OneFootball Chief Executive Officer Lucas von Cranach said in an emailed response to questions. 

“We are thrilled to have Victoire join the team and work with us to make the women’s game more accessible for a new generation of fans,” he said. 

Cogevina, an advocate for gender equality in soccer, had attracted OneFootball’s attention in a presentation at a company event in June, where she spoke about the future of women’s soccer. “We saw an opportunity to cement our relationship and bring her into the OneFootball squad,” he added. 

Several of Gloria’s backers will transfer their investment to OneFootball, including Reddit co-founder Alexis Ohanian, Initialized Capital founder Garry Tan, and Muse Capital co-founder Assia Grazioli-Venier. 

The companies didn’t disclose the size of the deal, which is expected to close next month. The Gloria app hasn’t formally launched and is still in beta testing, according to its website. 

“The women’s football effect is global, happening simultaneously on multiple continents,” Cogevina said. “Women’s football is the fastest-growing sport in the world and the most exciting sector in global football.”

The growing popularity of the games have been “nothing short of spectacular,” said Cogevina, pointing to a series of milestones over the past six months, including the Barcelona-Real Madrid women’s quarter final of the Champions League in March, which reached a global record of 91,533 fans at the stadium for a female soccer match. 

In August, the European soccer association, UEFA, released a study that estimated the fan base for the women’s game would grow to 328 million in the next ten years from 144 million. The commercial value of women’s football could expand sixfold to 686 million euros ($667.6 million) by 2033, it added.   

OneFootball, which counts more than 100 million monthly active users, provides access to soccer coverage from news to statistics, and also offers live football matches in-app on a free and pay-per-view basis. The Gloria purchase is part of a decision to broaden its user base. It aims to expand on its existing offerings on women’s soccer — which include news, statistics and video features — with new partnerships and increased advertising. 

OneFootball raised $300 million in April as part of a funding round led by blockchain fund Liberty City Ventures. It declined to say what proportion of its current user base is female, noting that the company is “working on an intensive deep dive to better understand the demographics of our user base.”

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

US Stocks Drop as Fed’s Hawkish Drumbeat Persists: Markets Wrap

(Bloomberg) — US stocks dropped as fresh data painted a picture of an economy that can handle further interest-rate hikes that Federal Reserve officials have been warning investors about. 

The S&P 500 fell as much as 2.7% after St. Louis Fed President James Bullard didn’t back down from his hawkish stance and said investors have now understood that they can’t escape additional rate hikes in coming months. Better-than-expected 2Q core PCE and personal consumption numbers on Thursday also paved the path for the central bank to stay aggressive. Weekly jobless claims fell to the lowest since April, showing a persistently tight labor market. 

The tech-heavy Nasdaq 100 fell as much as 3.4%. It was dragged down by a decline in Apple Inc. shares after the firm suffered a rare downgrade from Bank of America analysts, who warned of weaker consumer demand for its popular products. 

US Treasuries trimmed Wednesday’s gains, with the 10-year yield climbing to around 3.79%. UK gilt yields rose after Prime Minister Liz Truss’s defense of unfunded tax cuts that sent markets into turmoil failed to persuade investors. 

Investors are contending with threats posed by discordant moves from central banks over the past few days, with Fed officials adamant on further monetary tightening, the BOE unveiling a plan to support government debt and authorities in Asia trying to prop up weakening currencies.

“The market is down coming to terms with the idea that a recession is almost a given at this point and it’s really making adjustments for that,” said Shawn Snyder, head of investment strategy at Citi US Wealth Management. “You also have some turmoil going on in the United Kingdom, with the gilts taking a hit and currency tumbling due to the inflationary fiscal policy being projected there. And then you have the Nord Stream too, with some of the sabotage that could make things even worse, so I think all that combined is creating more jitters.”

Fed officials haven’t shied away from warning that more rate-hike pain is yet to come, with Cleveland Fed President Loretta Mester echoing the rhetoric that her colleagues reinforced this week. Recession fears persisted as a gap in the government’s two primary measures of US economic activity during the first half of 2022 narrowed. The National Bureau of Economic Research’s Business Cycle Dating Committee uses this metric and other variables to make any recession call.

For markets to stabilize, “investors will need to see convincing evidence that inflation is coming under control, allowing central banks to become less hawkish,” said Mark Haefele, chief investment officer at UBS Global Wealth Management. “This turn, in our view, is still some time away.”

Separately, the European Commission announced an eighth package of sanctions that would include a price cap on Russia’s oil exports as Russia vowed to go ahead with the annexation of the parts of Ukraine that its troops currently control after UN-condemned votes, putting the Kremlin on a fresh collision course with the US and its allies.

How much damage is a strong dollar causing? That’s the theme of this week’s MLIV Pulse survey. It’s brief and we don’t collect your name or any contact information. Please click here to share your views.

Key events this week:

  • Fed’s Mary Daly speak at an event, Thursday
  • China PMI, Friday
  • Euro zone CPI, unemployment, Friday
  • US consumer income , University of Michigan consumer sentiment, Friday
  • Fed’s Lael Brainard and John Williams speak, Friday

Some of the main moves in markets:

Stocks

  • The S&P 500 fell 2.2% as of 10:59 a.m. New York time
  • The Nasdaq 100 fell 2.9%
  • The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 1.6%
  • The Stoxx Europe 600 fell 2.1%
  • The MSCI World index rose 1.1%

Currencies

  • The Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index was little changed
  • The euro rose 0.3% to $0.9762
  • The British pound rose 1.3% to $1.1026
  • The Japanese yen fell 0.3% to 144.63 per dollar

Cryptocurrencies

  • Bitcoin fell 1.9% to $19,189.62
  • Ether fell 2.2% to $1,320.57

Bonds

  • The yield on 10-year Treasuries advanced six basis points to 3.79%
  • Germany’s 10-year yield advanced 11 basis points to 2.23%
  • Britain’s 10-year yield advanced 13 basis points to 4.14%

Commodities

  • West Texas Intermediate crude fell 0.5% to $81.74 a barrel
  • Gold futures fell 0.7% to $1,658.50 an ounce

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Bitcoin Could Be as Bad for the Planet as Beef

(Bloomberg) — Bitcoin mining’s climate impact is comparable to farming cattle or burning gasoline when taken as a proportion of market value, according to researchers at the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque. 

Cryptocurrency mining is energy intensive because it requires highly specialized computers — and most of the electricity it consumes is generated by burning planet-warming fossil fuels. The climate-related economic damage caused by mining the popular digital token, Bitcoin, exceeded its market value on 6.4% of the days it traded between 2016 and 2021,  the paper published in Scientific Reports on Thursday found.  

The study calculated the climate cost of mining Bitcoin against its average market price, and compared it with other commodities like crude oil, gold or beef. That means the results don’t reflect total emissions by these industries, which would be far greater, but their relative impact.

The climate impact of mining gold, to which Bitcoin is often compared, is just 4% of its average market price on an average year, compared to 35% for the world’s most popular cryptocurrency between 2016 and 2021.  And the environmental impact has grown as the cryptocurrency market has matured, calling into question the sector’s overall sustainability.

“While proponents have offered (Bitcoin) as representing ‘digital gold,’ from a climate damages perspective it operates more like ‘digital crude,’” the researchers said, signaling the need to find more efficient ways to produce the tokens, or to increase regulation.

Mining of Bitcoin, which represents roughly 41% of the global cryptocurrency market, consumed more energy than was used to power entire countries like Austria or Portugal in 2020. The mining of Bitcoin, Ether, Litecoin and Monero coins generated 3 to 15 million metric tons of carbon dioxide emissions from January 2016, to June 2018, according to research cited by the paper. That’s equivalent to the emissions of Afghanistan, Slovenia or Uruguay in 2018. 

Bitcoin’s carbon footprint also grows over time because, to mine new coins, multiple miners compete to verify transactions on the blockchain.  The fact that an ever-growing number of miners compete to solve increasingly difficult operations means the overall energy use rises. 

That’s why a Bitcoin mined in 2021 would have emitted about 113 metric tons of CO2 equivalent — 126 times more than one mined in 2016, according to the researchers. The paper estimates the economic value of that damage at $11,314 for a single Bitcoin mined last year, while the value of total climate damages generated by all Bitcoins mined between 2016 and 2021 could have been as high as $12 billion. 

In recent months, plunging profit margins from mining Bitcoin have pushed miners to operate more efficient machines — a move that’s resulted in a decline in greenhouse gas emissions  from the industry, according to a different report earlier this week. Emissions this year are estimated to be 14.1% lower than in 2021, representing about 0.1% of human emissions globally, and about half of what gold miners generate in absolute terms. 

Cryptocurrency miners are also ramping up efforts to source a larger share of the energy they consume from renewable sources like geothermal, hydro, solar and wind. Researchers at the University of Albuquerque ran a simulation and concluded that, if renewables like wind and solar had represented 88.4% of the total amount of power used to mine Bitcoin between 2016 and 2021, climate damages would have dropped to just 4% of average market price. 

Another way to reduce climate impact is to shift to a different mechanism to verify transactions — and produce coins. Ether, the second largest cryptocurrency, this year moved to a mechanism called Proof of Stake, which the study said should reduce its estimated energy use by more than 99%.

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com

©2022 Bloomberg L.P.

Close Bitnami banner
Bitnami